Questions and Answers :
Windows :
3 times longer runtimes under Win 11?
Message board moderation
| Author | Message |
|---|---|
|
Send message Joined: 20 Jul 20 Posts: 3 Credit: 1,305,656 RAC: 0 |
Hi there, I have just updated to Win 11. The chip driver which should patch the AMD issues is also installed. However my runtime for GPU tasks are now more than 3 times longer as under Win 10: Win 10: always around 4000 sec Win 11: 14:000 sec https://www.mlcathome.org/mlcathome/workunit.php?wuid=5755061 Has anybody else made the same experience? Greetings Marcus |
|
Send message Joined: 30 Jun 20 Posts: 462 Credit: 21,406,548 RAC: 0 |
Thanks for reporting. We haven't tested on Windows 11, much less cuda on windows 11. We'll add it to the list, but I suspect this is a windows 11/cuda driver maturity issue. Have you seen similar slowdowns with other projects' WUs? |
|
Send message Joined: 9 Jul 20 Posts: 142 Credit: 11,536,204 RAC: 3 |
As far as I can tell, the slowdown of your runtimes are not (only) connected to your Win11 upgrade. Just take a look at your stderr file output of your slower task vs. faster ones prior to your upgrade: Prior to upgrade (Quick task) [2021-10-23 18:12:53 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1556 | loss: 0.0311986 | val_loss: 0.0312002 | Time: 1904.55 ms [2021-10-23 18:12:55 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1557 | loss: 0.0311993 | val_loss: 0.0312003 | Time: 1928.85 ms [2021-10-23 18:12:57 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1558 | loss: 0.0311996 | val_loss: 0.0312058 | Time: 1899.59 ms [2021-10-23 18:12:59 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1559 | loss: 0.0312017 | val_loss: 0.0312017 | Time: 1945.45 ms [2021-10-23 18:13:01 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1560 | loss: 0.0311992 | val_loss: 0.0312004 | Time: 1947.02 ms [2021-10-23 18:13:03 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1561 | loss: 0.0312008 | val_loss: 0.0312009 | Time: 1929.72 ms Runtime: 4,057 sec & CPU time: 3,881 sec After upgrade (Slow task) [2021-10-24 15:38:04 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1546 | loss: 0.0310213 | val_loss: 0.0312575 | Time: 8615.13 ms [2021-10-24 15:38:12 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1547 | loss: 0.0310251 | val_loss: 0.0312677 | Time: 7332.4 ms [2021-10-24 15:38:22 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1548 | loss: 0.0310204 | val_loss: 0.0312522 | Time: 9820.51 ms [2021-10-24 15:38:30 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1549 | loss: 0.0310245 | val_loss: 0.0312602 | Time: 8587.51 ms [2021-10-24 15:38:37 main:574] : INFO : Epoch 1550 | loss: 0.0310288 | val_loss: 0.031248 | Time: 6888.06 ms Runtime: 14,101 sec & CPU time: 10,746 sec The variation in computing time per epoch should be marginal only, but in the slow task, it does vary considerably with ∆(deviation) approaching max ~4sec or almost 58%. That combined with the larger gap between runtime and CPU time stays to show that some other system process is infringing the computing process. It seems that your CPU is overcommitted, maybe even through some Win11 upgrade related background processes. And while you're at it, it wouldn't hurt to upgrade your GPU driver. Currently you have installed version 456.71. According to NVIDIA's driver page, the latest version is 496.13. :) Hope that helps! |
|
Send message Joined: 20 Jul 20 Posts: 3 Credit: 1,305,656 RAC: 0 |
updating the driver was my fist reaction. But this does not help. WU still need about 4 hours. The GPU is showing around 5 % usage in the task manger. So it seems also not over-committed but the other way round. I have never checked GPU usage for MLC but for example milkyway has about 85 % GPU usage. |
|
Send message Joined: 17 Jul 20 Posts: 12 Credit: 7,473,347 RAC: 65 |
Try to increase mlds-gpu_9.75_windows-x86_64__cuda10200 priority to realtime. |
|
Send message Joined: 23 Sep 20 Posts: 24 Credit: 15,318,198 RAC: 1,992 |
It seems that your CPU is overcommitted, maybe even through some Win11 upgrade related background processes. I noticed an almost 20% run time increase working CPU units using Windows 11. That's why I switched back to Windows 10. |
|
Send message Joined: 20 Jul 20 Posts: 3 Credit: 1,305,656 RAC: 0 |
Try to increase mlds-gpu_9.75_windows-x86_64__cuda10200 priority to realtime. How? |
©2022 MLC@Home Team
A project of the Cognition, Robotics, and Learning (CORAL) Lab at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County (UMBC)